Mini Mayhem

Sharing our family's love of life, books, adventure, and mayhem: to "live deep, and suck out all the marrow of life" (Thoreau, 1854).

Miss, That’s Not An Orange

My teaching practicum was in Cairo, Egypt. I don’t think that’s really a thing anymore, which is unfortunate, because I don’t think I’ve ever learned so much in all my life than when I’ve been abroad, stumbling my way through streets and interactions and hoping I don’t step on any toes as I fumble and learn my way around. I worked at a BC International School, and the curriculum and daily processes were much the same as they are in my Okanagan school, with the exception of sand storm season and the havoc it wreaked on the photocopy room in our largely roofless school. Though a couple of my students had actually been to or lived in Canada, most were Egyptian nationals whose families paid rather large sums of money to allow their children to attend this private school and in that regard, my experience was rather unlike any other I could imagine.

A view of the Great Pyramid of Giza, surrounded by arid desert landscape, with people and horses walking in the foreground.
Photo credit: Megan Owens (2009). Our daily route to school passed the Great Pyramid of Giza, and I could never quite catch my breath upon seeing it, even after several months in Egypt.

One memorable day, students had a project that involved making a fruit salad for their class. Every student at the class grew up in a home with a full household and kitchen staff, and had never been required to cut or prepare food in any way. At one point we asked a student to pass the oranges, and she insisted there weren’t any.

“Of course there are, there’s a whole bowl on the counter!”

“Miss, that’s not an orange. An orange is a small wedge that’s soft and squishy.”

In all her years, she had never once seen an unpeeled, unsegmented orange, and honestly, I barely knew how to respond! Even more common was asking students for their homework, only to hear that their maid had not reminded them to do it, and so it simply wasn’t done. Having returned to Canada and since then worked for 12 of my 17 teaching years at an alternate school, I now encounter eerily similar yet polar opposite conversations regularly. Do my students know what fruit looks like with the peel on? Absolutely. But do some of them actually have access to fresh fruit and veggies regularly? Not always, and even more of them struggle to find a way to do assigned homework outside of the school. This is not for lack of reminders from their household staff, but because they lack access to or knowledge of how to use the tools with which to complete work that is often assigned online, or requires writing and calculating to successfully do.

Food and housing insecurities are issues that go beyond the personal into society, and with good reason, they garner a fair amount of attention. Equally pressing however, is the digital discrepancy that we see between households of unequal socioeconomic means, and the negative social and economic consequences that follow. As Dawn Wacek eloquently states in her TedX talk, without access to books and the services that libraries provide in gaining access to online knowledge and resources, “we know we have that 30 million word gap and a corresponding achievement gap by the time kids enter the third grade, both of which directly correlate to income level” (February 2018). “Why would we continue to operate under a model that hurts our most vulnerable patrons the most? (ibid). What then, is our responsibility as librarians and purveyors of access to all kinds of knowledge?

Dawn Wacek (2018) speaks of the La Crosse Library initiatives to create equity in access to digital and physical resources at the library, regardless of “good standing” or age, and the immense benefit to underserved members of society this provides.

We must, at all costs, work together to create ongoing equity in access to information and the many services and resources that libraries provide, perhaps most especially including how to use these resources. Access to online databases and job applications, college and university courses, word processing, language learning, and tutorials on how to use digital resources and databases are just a few of the life-changing access points that are vital to a diverse society, and that are sometimes offered only through local libraries. But what happens when this access is blocked, by age or an overdue or lost item, or simply by a lack of ability to communicate need or lack of understanding?

Several people pushing a vehicle stuck in the sand near rocky cliffs in a desert landscape.
Image credit: Megan Owens (2009). Working together to get out of a sinking situation in the White Desert, Egypt.

In 2020, BC Libraries Cooperative released a planning guide detailing approaches and considerations regarding the lending of connectivity tools. This document directly contradicts Ms. Wacek’s arguments, on the grounds that damaged and missing items would likely cost libraries too much to continue the program. In fact, Toronto Libraries lost funding for a similar project in 2018, leaving connectivity in underserviced communities to the local libraries themselves. Indeed, Surrey Libraries have restricted their Chromebook lending program to in-library only, and for a maximum of three hours at a time, while fortunately still lending out digital coding kits and other interesting devices (Surrey Libraries, 2026). In limiting access, we are also limiting possibilities as well as the potential to learn how to effectively use access once it’s obtained. Practice, after all, makes perfect.

Equity doesn’t stop at mere access though, and diversity is so much more than socioeconomic. Many patrons of the library have no other means to access or use information due to disability, and these are the patrons who often suffer the most from lack of access or insufficient knowledge regarding how to make these digital tools work for them. The American Library Association’s 2025 “Planning for Digital Accessibility and Literacy” discusses how to perform an accessibility audit on the library’s website, as well as the databases it accesses. This assists folks who use screen readers, audio descriptions, and captions to fully access digital resources. They also discuss how a library can plan for digital literacy among its staff and patrons, ensuring equitable access to resources.

American Library Association (2025, December 3). This webinar describes digital literacy, where it is needed and why, and how libraries can optimize their digital accessibility for patrons.

Digital access to resources doesn’t stop in our own communities, and in a librarian’s own quest for access and publicity for digital literacy, one must also champion access and literacy for all. Speaking up for the rural communities who are underserved, for those who may not be able to access their library and need a mobile hotspot or laptop, or those who are unable to access digital resources at home due to disability or required adaptations, or those who need to learn how to use the tools at their disposal; all of this is connected to the library’s own journey to ongoing equity (which constantly changes and evolves). There will always be a member of a community who needs access, whether adapted or not, and until it is there, the digital divide will only continue to grow (Mission Telecom, 2026).

Libraries For Development (IREX, 2026) and Libraries Without Borders (n.d.) both create ways for underserved communities across the world to access digital resources and information, as well as distribute physical books and services. By supporting these endeavours, libraries and their staff encourage their community to learn about and address digital literacy and access issues in their home communities and those far away, and perhaps find ways to support the processes. In-house learning sessions, devices available for loan, digital accessibility audits ensuring that all users can access and utilize all information; these are just starting points for libraries. After all, a society that reads together, grows together. A society without access to knowledge is one that is doomed to repeat its mistakes.

Close-up view of a large, textured stone wall with inscriptions, beside a reflective water feature and blue sky with scattered clouds.
Image credit: Megan Owens (2009). The Library of Alexandria: an access point to history, knowledge, and what we stand to lose.

American Library Association (2025, December 3). Planning for Digital Accessibility and Literacy: Edi and Neal’s Book Club December 2025 Webinar. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K5BmghBvVxQ

BC Libraries Cooperative. (2020, November). Lending Connectivity Tools: A Library Planning Guide. https://bc.libraries.coop/

Mission Telecom (2026, January 6). Libraries Help Bridge the Digital Divide in Creative Ways. Library Journal. https://www.libraryjournal.com/story/libraries-help-bridge-the-digital-divide-in-creative-ways-lj251219

Surrey Libraries (2026). Tech To Go. https://www.surreylibraries.ca/books-media/tech-go

Wacek, Dawn (2018). A librarian’s case against overdue book fines. Ted Talks. https://www.ted.com/talks/dawn_wacek_a_librarian_s_case_against_overdue_book_fines

Comments

7 responses to “Miss, That’s Not An Orange”

  1. Shareen Hando Avatar
    Shareen Hando

    I really enjoyed reading this post! The orange story was such a great example of how our experiences can shape what we know and sometimes what we take for granted. It also made me think about how different forms of privilege and barriers can exist, even when they look completely different on the surface. I especially connected with your point that access isn’t enough on its own. People also need the knowledge, confidence, and support to use the resources available to them. Thanks for sharing such a thoughtful reflection and giving me a new way to think about equity and the role libraries play in our communities. – Shareen H

  2. Jessica Erwin Avatar
    Jessica Erwin

    Megan, I really enjoyed this, particularly your orange story and the strange inversion between your students in Cairo and those you now teach in BC. It connected closely to something I found myself wrestling with in my own inquiry: the difference between having access to something and actually having the knowledge or capacity to use it. I began teaching in South Africa, where the material divide was impossible to miss, so I think I have always rather simplistically equated access with equity. Your point that libraries need to provide not only digital resources but also the knowledge of how to use them really resonated with me. I am increasingly realizing that the device, database, or internet connection is only the beginning; without the human support that helps someone make meaningful use of it, we may have solved the easiest part of the problem and congratulated ourselves slightly too soon.

  3. Alexis Cherniak Avatar
    Alexis Cherniak

    Megan, your comparison between teaching in Cairo and Canada was really interesting. I had a similar experience working at the Canadian International School in Hong Kong, where families also spent large amounts of money to attend. Your orange story stood out to me because it shows how different people’s experiences can be and how we sometimes take things for granted. I also liked your discussion about digital equity and how libraries help students access technology and learn how to use it. It reminded me that not everyone has the same resources at home, and as educators, we need to understand these differences and make sure all students have the support they need to succeed.

  4. Amanda Hill Avatar
    Amanda Hill

    What a hook! I was completely captivated by your description of teaching in Egypt and eager to keep reading.

    Thank you as well for drawing attention to the issue of accessibility, as it is often overlooked in conversations about technology. Access is about much more than simply having a device. It also involves having the necessary supports, infrastructure, and opportunities to use technology in meaningful ways.

    Reading your post made me think about some of the incredible organizations working to address these challenges here in British Columbia. SET-BC (https://www.setbc.org/technology/loan-bank/) supports school districts by lending assistive technology and providing services for students with diverse learning needs. Beyond schools, organizations such as the Neil Squire Society (https://www.neilsquire.ca/individual-programs-services/computer-comfort/) provide assistive technology assessments, computer training, and refurbished computers for people with disabilities, helping to remove barriers to participation in education, employment, and community life.

    I was also reminded of initiatives such as reBOOT Canada (https://www.rebootcanada.ca/programs/restart/) and ReuseTechBC (https://reusetechbc.ca/request), which refurbish and redistribute computers to low-income individuals, families, schools, Indigenous communities, libraries, and non-profit organizations.

    These organizations demonstrate that increasing accessibility requires more than simply providing internet access; it also means ensuring that people have access to devices, assistive technologies, training, and ongoing support so they can fully participate in learning and community life.

  5. klim Avatar
    klim

    As others have said, your opening was very compelling! The stark contrast of experiences really makes issues apparent such as accessing technology for school, or even fresh fruits and vegetables.

    There’s been a lot of talk across my district about the diversity audits that were done a few years ago, but I hadn’t heard of an accessibility audit before. My local public library has high visibility keyboards at the circulation computers to reduce eye strain for seniors or others with low vision. It was something that stuck out to me when the change happened because they’re bright yellow. I am interested to take my time and think about the layout of the library from an accessibility lens the next time I’m there!

  6. Darcy McNee Avatar
    Darcy McNee

    As others have commented, your opening immediately drew me into your post. I appreciate how you connected your experiences in Egypt and Canada to show that issues of equity can look very different on the surface while still creating barriers for learners. The discussion of accessibility, programs and organizations helped expand the conversation beyond simply providing devices and internet access. I appreciate the insight you shared about the connection between access and opportunity, and the reminder that the digital divide is often intertwined with many other forms of inequity that students experience. Your images added another engaging aspect to the post.

  7. Gabriella Rainforth Avatar
    Gabriella Rainforth

    Hi Megan, I am joining in with what others have been commenting! I really enjoyed your personal story from your practicum experience in Cairo. Reading your story is an example of the unique opportunity afforded to us through blogging our assignments, which allows us insights into each other’s teaching experiences that we would not otherwise get.

    Your story reminded me of the importance of really meeting our students where they are at- whether that be teaching them what whole fruits look like or teaching them the fundamentals of using a device for homework. We may come into a teaching experience expecting our students to have certain background knowledge already, but your post is a good reminder of the vastly different experiences our students might have outside of the classroom. I appreciate the reminder to slow down when teaching and see where everyone is at. I think this would be especially important to consider when I am a teacher-librarian interacting with all the students in the school, rather than with a single class of students where it is inherently easier to get to know them and their backgrounds.

Leave a Reply